TianEon
解 Release

Hexagram 40 as yes or no

Hexagram 40 Release as a yes-or-no answer

releasedeliverancerelief

Xie answers 'should I' with 'yes, and soon' — or with 'no, and go home'. The Judgment is unusually operational: if there is nowhere you need to go, returning to the old order is fortunate; if there is somewhere to go, going early is fortunate. The one thing the hexagram rules out is lingering. The obstruction that preceded it is over, and the question is not whether to act but whether any action is still called for. If it is, the time is now rather than later; if it is not, the right answer is to let the matter close.

The changing line tells you which case you are in. In the lower trigram the answer leans toward 'return': line one, no action needed, rest; line two, yes to clearing up the small complications, done straight and quickly; line three, no — what you are contemplating puts you above your station and invites trouble. In the upper trigram the answer leans toward 'go early': line four, yes, let go of the lesser attachment now; line five, yes, disengage decisively and the rest resolves itself; line six, yes, the last obstacle is in view and this is the moment to remove it.

The hexagram in brief

Thunder and rain: the storm breaks and tension dissolves. Favourable to the southwest; if there is nowhere to go, returning brings good fortune; if there is, act early.

Release what was knotted — forgive, settle, finish quickly — then return to normal without lingering.

The judgment

解:利西南,无所往,其來復吉。有攸往,夙吉。

In (the state indicated by) Kieh advantage will be found in the south-west. If no (further) operations be called for, there will be good fortune in coming back (to the old conditions). If some operations be called for, there will be good fortune in the early conducting of them.

Which line changed?

A changing line sharpens the answer. Each line of 解 Release has its own page:

  1. 初六Six at the beginningno fault · where hard meets soft · simply rest
  2. 九二Nine in the second placethree foxes · the yellow arrow · the straight middle way
  3. 六三Six in the third placea porter in a carriage · inviting robbers · self-inflicted
  4. 九四Nine in the fourth placerelease your toe · letting go of the unworthy · friends come
  5. 六五Six in the fifth placethe superior person unties · small people withdraw · trust shown
  6. 上六Six at the topshooting the hawk · the high wall · removing the last rebel

Questions

Does hexagram 40, Release, mean yes or no?
Xie answers 'should I' with 'yes, and soon' — or with 'no, and go home'. The Judgment is unusually operational: if there is nowhere you need to go, returning to the old order is fortunate; if there is somewhere to go, going early is fortunate. The one thing the hexagram rules out is lingering. The obstruction that preceded it is over, and the question is not whether to act but whether any action is still called for. If it is, the time is now rather than later; if it is not, the right answer is to let the matter close.
What does Hexagram 40, 解 Release, mean?
Thunder and rain: the storm breaks and tension dissolves. Favourable to the southwest; if there is nowhere to go, returning brings good fortune; if there is, act early.

Chinese text: the received Zhouyi (Wuyingdian lineage). English: James Legge, The Yî King, Sacred Books of the East XVI, 1882 (public domain).

Hexagram 40 Release (解) as a yes or no answer · TianEon